Devoted exclusively to Florida community associations since 2011 Call today: 239-594-7227

Director Conflict of Interest Checklist: Running a Conflicted Transaction So It Holds

How a Florida board identifies a director conflict, takes the written disclosure, votes it properly and posts the record, with the three chapters compared side by side.

A director's company can do work for the association. The statutes do not forbid it. What they forbid is doing it quietly. Almost every conflict problem a board has is a disclosure problem, a counting problem or a records problem, and each of the three is avoidable in about ten minutes at the meeting. Work down this list before the vote, not after the complaint.

Download the PDFThe PDF is a designed, printable copy for the board packet, the bulletin board or your meeting portfolio. On screen, you can tick the boxes below; nothing you tick is saved or sent anywhere.

The three chapters do not run conflicts the same way. Condominiums have a dedicated section at § 718.3027. HOAs have one at § 720.3033(2). Chapter 719 has no counterpart, so a cooperative board runs the transaction under the nonprofit corporation provision at § 617.0832. Where the mechanics differ, the difference is stated under the item.

Identify the conflict

  • § 718.3027(1); § 720.3033(2); § 617.0832
  • § 718.3027(1)(a), (1)(b)
  • § 617.0832(1)(a)
  • The statutory presumptions are written around contracts. The fiduciary duty is not.

Work out who counts as a relative

  • Third degree reaches parents, children, siblings, grandparents, grandchildren, aunts, uncles, nieces, nephews and great-grandparents, and the same relations by marriage. It is broader than most directors assume.§ 718.3027(6); § 468.4335
  • § 617.0832(1)(c)
  • The documents can be stricter. They cannot be looser.

Take the written disclosure

  • § 718.3027(1); § 720.3033(2); § 617.0832(3)
  • Chapter 720 contains a 14-day advance disclosure requirement. Confirm the subsection with counsel; verification passes have placed it in more than one place.
  • This is a hard statutory requirement, not good practice. An agenda that says 'vendor proposal' with nothing attached does not satisfy it.§ 718.3027(2)
  • § 718.3027(2); § 720.3033(2)

Run the vote

  • § 718.3027(4)
  • This matters on a small board. The quorum does not fail because the conflicted director stepped out.§ 718.3027(4)
  • The denominator excludes the interested director. On a five-member board with all present, that is two-thirds of four, so three votes.§ 718.3027(2)
  • Chapter 720 phrases the denominator differently from Chapter 718. Count it the way your chapter phrases it and record the arithmetic in the minutes.§ 720.3033(2)
  • Under § 617.0832 an interested director's presence and vote do not by themselves invalidate the action, and the interested director may be counted toward quorum. The safe route is still a disinterested-director vote.§ 617.0832(4)
  • § 718.111(1)(b)
  • § 617.0832(3)
  • § 617.0832(1)(b), (2)

Tell the members, and respect their right to cancel

  • § 718.3027(2); § 720.3033(2)
  • § 718.3027(2); § 720.3033(2)
  • § 718.3027(2); § 720.3033(2)
  • Twenty percent of the owners can end an undisclosed insider contract without a lawsuit and without the board's agreement.§ 718.3027(5)
  • § 718.3027(3)

The manager's conflicts are a separate problem

  • § 468.4335
  • § 468.4335
  • The threshold is low and it catches routine work. Build it into the management agreement so the manager is not deciding case by case.§ 468.4335
  • This is the strongest termination right most boards have and most boards do not know they have it.§ 468.4335
  • Our management agreement review page covers the other clauses to fix at the same time.

Kickbacks are not a conflict problem

  • § 720.3033(3)
  • There is no disclosure that cures a kickback. This is not a transaction the board can approve by two-thirds.§ 720.3033(3)
  • § 720.3033(3)

Records and posting

  • § 718.111(12); § 719.104(2); § 720.303(4)
  • § 718.111(12)(g)2.
  • § 718.111(12)(g)2.
  • § 720.303(4)(b); § 718.111(12)(g)
  • § 719.104(2)
  • § 718.111(12)(c); § 719.104(2)(c); § 720.303(5)(g)
CondominiumHOACooperative
Governing provision§ 718.3027§ 720.3033(2)§ 617.0832 (Ch. 719 has no counterpart)
Relative reachedThird degree of consanguinity by blood or marriageSee § 720.3033 and § 617.0832Chapter 617 family member: spouse, children, parents, grandparents, siblings
Agenda listing and attachmentsRequired by statuteConfirm with counselNot specified
Board vote to approveTwo-thirds of all other directors presentTwo-thirds of the directors presentMajority of disinterested directors, or member approval, or fairness
Interested director and quorumAttendance constitutes a quorum for the vote taken in his or her absenceNot specifiedMay be counted toward quorum
Members may cancelMajority vote at the next meetingMajority vote on motion of any memberNot specified
Undisclosed contractVoidable; terminates on written notice with consent of 20 percent of voting interestsNot specifiedFairness analysis under § 617.0832

Statutes and authorities referenced

Contact Hamilton Mikes

Hamilton Mikes reviews conflicted transactions for Southwest Florida boards before the vote, drafts disclosure and gift policies, and handles the management agreement clauses that keep a manager's conflicts in the open. Call 239-594-7227 or visit our Corporate Governance page.

We're ready to help

Speak with a Florida community association attorney

Tell us about your association and the legal challenge you are facing. Our team is ready to listen, respond, and help you identify a clear path forward.

239-594-7227 Info@HamiltonMikes.com
Hamilton Mikes, P.A.
8850 Terrene Court, Suite 110
Bonita Springs, FL 34135
How would you like to be contacted?

Fields marked * are required. Or call 239-594-7227.