Devoted exclusively to Florida community associations since 2011 Call today: 239-594-7227

The Board Minute · No. 16

Is this Really the Association’s Responsibility?

When an owner and the association disagree about who pays for a repair, start with authority, then the facts, then the impact.

“Who pays?”

It sounds like a simple question. But in a community association, the answer isn’t always obvious.

A roof leak. A damaged pipe. A fallen tree. A repair to a wall, window, or shared system.

An owner may believe the association should handle it. The association may believe it’s the owners responsibility. And sometimes, both sides have a reasonable basis for asking the question.

Before deciding who pays, take a step back.

Start with authority.

What do the governing documents say about maintenance, repairs, and replacement? Does the applicable law address the issue? Who is responsible for the particular component involved?

Then consider the facts.

Where is the problem located? What caused the damage? Is the issue related to a component the association maintains, an owner’s responsibility, or something that requires a closer look?

Finally, consider the impact.

Who will bear the cost? Could the decision affect how similar situations are handled in the future? Are there other owners or shared components involved?

The important thing is not to decide based on assumptions, past practice alone, or simply who seems most likely to be responsible.

And remember: responsibility for maintaining something and responsibility for paying for a particular repair aren’t always the same question.

The answer depends on the applicable law, the governing documents, and the circumstances.

The next time the question comes up, start here:

Before deciding who pays, make sure you understand why.

We're ready to help

Speak with a Florida community association attorney

Tell us about your association and the legal challenge you are facing. Our team is ready to listen, respond, and help you identify a clear path forward.

239-594-7227 Info@HamiltonMikes.com
Hamilton Mikes, P.A.
8850 Terrene Court, Suite 110
Bonita Springs, FL 34135
How would you like to be contacted?

Fields marked * are required. Or call 239-594-7227.