A Florida cooperative is governed by a set of instruments rather than a single declaration. Chapter 719 calls them the cooperative documents and defines them in § 719.103(13), but the practical set a board works with is larger: the articles of incorporation, the bylaws, the board's rules, the share certificate or membership evidence, and the proprietary lease that each resident holds. Which one controls a given question is not obvious, because Chapter 719 never sets out the order of authority in so many words.
What Chapter 719 calls a cooperative document
Section 719.103(13) groups the documents into three categories. The first is the documents that create the cooperative, which include the articles of incorporation, the bylaws, and any ground lease or other underlying lease. The second is the document that evidences a member's ownership interest, usually a share certificate or membership certificate. The third is the document that recognizes the member's title or right of possession to a particular unit, which in practice is the proprietary lease or occupancy agreement.
That third category is the one with no condominium counterpart, and it is why the document set reads differently. In a condominium the declaration both creates the regime and describes each owner's property. In a cooperative the creating documents establish the entity and the property, and a separate instrument, granted by the association to each resident, establishes that resident's right to occupy a specific unit.
Section 719.1035(2) gives the whole set its force: "All provisions of the cooperative documents are enforceable equitable servitudes, run with the land, and are effective until the cooperative is terminated." A purchaser takes subject to them whether or not the purchaser read them.
The set in practice
- Articles of incorporation. The corporate charter. It creates the entity, states its purpose, and usually sets the number of directors and the basic membership structure. Corporate formalities run from here and from chapter 617.
- Bylaws. The operating manual, and in a cooperative the bylaws carry an unusual amount of statutory content. Section 719.106(1) lists what the bylaws must provide, paragraph by paragraph, from the composition of the board through fines and delinquencies.
- The proprietary lease or occupancy agreement. The contract between the association as owner and each resident as occupant. It states what the resident may do inside the unit, what the resident pays, and what happens on default.
- Share or membership certificate. The evidence of ownership described in § 719.105(1)(a), which must include a legal description of each dwelling unit and must be recorded as required by § 201.02(3).
- Rules and regulations. Adopted by the board or the members, depending on what the bylaws provide. Section 719.106(2)(a) contemplates the bylaws providing a method of adopting and amending administrative rules governing details of the operation and use of the common areas.
- Underlying leases. Some cooperatives sit on a ground lease or carry a long-term recreation lease. Those instruments bind the association and, through the common expense structure, the residents. Section 719.112 creates a rebuttable presumption that certain long-term leases entered into before the owners controlled the association are unconscionable.
Section 719.106(2)(b) also lets the bylaws set restrictions on and requirements for the use, maintenance and appearance of the units and the use of the common areas. That paragraph is the ordinary source of a co-op's use restrictions, and it sits alongside whatever the proprietary lease independently says about use.
Which document controls
This is the question boards most often get wrong, and it deserves a direct answer: Chapter 719 does not give you one. There is no provision in the Cooperative Act that sets out a hierarchy the way practitioners recite it. What the chapter gives you are pieces.
- The statute is on top. Section 719.104(11) provides that the powers and duties of the association include those set forth in the section and those set forth in the articles of incorporation and bylaws and part I of chapter 607 and chapter 617. Where Chapter 719 imposes a mandatory requirement, the documents cannot take it away.
- Corporate law fills gaps. The same subsection brings in part I of chapter 607 and chapter 617, which supply the default corporate rules on directors, officers, meetings and records that Chapter 719 does not address.
- The bylaws yield to the chapter and to the cooperative documents. Section 719.106(2) permits the bylaws to contain optional provisions, and § 719.106(1)(h) requires the bylaws to state a method of amendment consistent with the provisions of the chapter.
- Rules yield to everything above them. A rule adopted under a bylaw provision cannot exceed the authority the bylaw grants, and it cannot contradict the proprietary lease.
The customary ladder practitioners use, running statute, then articles, then bylaws, then the proprietary lease and rules, is a reasonable working assumption drawn from those pieces plus general corporate and contract law. It is not a quotation from the statute, and a board should not treat it as one when the stakes are real. Where the bylaws and the proprietary lease genuinely conflict, the answer usually turns on what each instrument was drafted to do and when each was last amended, and that is a question for counsel rather than for the table.
How the proprietary lease interacts with the rest
The proprietary lease is different in kind from the other documents. The bylaws and the articles are corporate instruments that bind the membership as a body. The proprietary lease is a contract between the association and one identified resident, and each resident holds a separate copy of it.
Three practical consequences follow. First, the lease usually contains remedies the statute does not, including default and termination provisions. Second, the lease is where maintenance, alterations, insurance and subletting are actually allocated, because Chapter 719 says little about any of them. Third, the lease is what a share lender reads, and a recognition agreement typically modifies how the association may use its lease remedies.
Because the lease is a contract each resident holds, amending it is not the same exercise as amending the bylaws. A lease amendment reaches both the corporate side and the contract side, and a board should not assume that whatever vote amends the bylaws also amends every resident's lease. Our guide to the proprietary lease itself goes through its covenants in detail.
What the bylaws must contain
Section 719.106(1) is where most of a co-op board's operating law lives. The paragraphs run in this order.
| Paragraph | Subject |
|---|---|
| (1)(a) | Administration: officers, composition of the board, eligibility |
| (1)(b) | Quorum, voting requirements and proxies |
| (1)(c) | Board meetings, openness and notice |
| (1)(d) | Shareholder meetings, annual meeting, elections and director certification |
| (1)(e) | Budget procedures and assessment approval |
| (1)(f) | Recall of board members |
| (1)(g) | Common expenses and collection |
| (1)(h) | Amendment of the bylaws |
| (1)(i) | Transfer fees |
| (1)(j) | Annual budget and reserve accounts |
| (1)(k) | Structural integrity reserve study |
| (1)(l) | Mandatory milestone inspections |
| (1)(m) | Insurance or fidelity bonding of persons who control association funds |
| (1)(n) | Alternative dispute resolution |
| (1)(o) | Director or officer delinquencies |
Older cooperative bylaws will not contain most of this. A set drafted in 1978 has nothing on reserve studies, milestone inspections or director certification, and reading only that document produces wrong answers. Treat the statutory list as part of your operating rules whether or not the bylaws were ever updated to match, and then decide separately whether to amend the bylaws so the paper reflects the practice. Our guide to cooperative board meeting requirements works through the § 719.106(1)(c) rules in detail.
Amending the cooperative documents
Amendment procedure is in § 719.1055, and the first thing to know about that section is its age. Its history line ends with ch. 2013-188, so unlike § 719.106 it has not moved in the recent legislative waves. The second thing to know is that it is a gap-filler as much as a rule: it tells you what happens when your documents do not provide a method.
- Amendments that change a unit or an owner's share. Under § 719.1055(1), an amendment that changes the configuration or size of a unit, its appurtenances, or a unit owner's proportion of common expenses requires the record owner of the unit and all record owners of liens on it to join in the execution of the amendment, and requires the record owners of all other units to approve. This is the provision that makes reallocating expense shares in a cooperative slow and document-intensive.
- Acquiring property or making material alterations. Section 719.1055(2) addresses acquisition of property and material alterations or substantial additions, approved by two-thirds of the voting interests unless the documents set a lower threshold or prohibit the action.
- Altering or leasing common areas. Section 719.1055(2) permits the association to alter, convert, lease or otherwise modify common areas on approval of two-thirds of the voting interests, unless the documents provide a different procedure or prohibit it.
- No method in the documents. Section 719.1055(4)(a) provides that where the cooperative documents fail to provide a method of amendment, an amendment other than one under subsection (1) requires approval by not less than two-thirds of the units.
- Bylaws specifically. Section 719.106(1)(h) requires the bylaws to state the method by which they may be amended consistent with the chapter, and provides that if the bylaws fail to state a method, they may be amended on approval of owners of not less than two-thirds of the voting interests.
Two mechanical rules catch boards out. Section 719.1055(4)(b) requires the amendment to set out the full text of the provision being amended, with new words underlined and deleted words lined through with hyphens, unless the proposed change is so extensive that the markup would hinder rather than assist understanding, in which case the amendment may carry the notation that there has been a substantial rewording of the document with a pointer to the provision for the present text. Section 719.1055(4)(c) then provides that nonmaterial errors or omissions in the amendment process do not invalidate an otherwise properly promulgated amendment.
That last provision is a safety net, not a plan. It forgives the nonmaterial. It does not forgive a missed vote threshold, a missing joinder under subsection (1), or a notice that never went out.
What to do with an aging document set
- Assemble the complete set, including every recorded amendment, the current bylaws with all amendments consolidated, the form of proprietary lease actually in use, and the rules currently enforced. Many co-ops discover at this step that the lease in the files is not the lease the residents hold.
- Compare the bylaws against the § 719.106(1) list and mark every paragraph the bylaws do not address. Those are the places the statute is doing work your documents do not acknowledge.
- Identify the subjects on which Chapter 719 is silent and the documents are also silent. Insurance allocation, reconstruction after a casualty, succession on the death of a shareholder, and lease termination are the usual four. Those are gaps, and they surface at the worst possible moment.
- Decide what to amend and in what order, and confirm the vote threshold for each instrument separately before circulating anything. The remedies available to your association often depend on language that can only be fixed by amendment.
- Calendar a document review every few years, rather than only after a dispute.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cooperative Governing Documents
What are the cooperative documents?
Section 719.103(13) defines them in three categories: the documents creating the cooperative, which include the articles of incorporation, the bylaws and any ground lease; the document evidencing the member's ownership interest or shares; and the document recognizing the member's title or right of possession to a unit, which is the proprietary lease or occupancy agreement.
If the bylaws and the proprietary lease conflict, which one wins?
Chapter 719 does not answer that directly, which is the honest answer a board should hear. The statute is on top of both, and § 719.106(2) requires optional bylaw provisions to be consistent with the chapter and the cooperative documents. Beyond that, a genuine conflict between the two turns on what each instrument was drafted to govern and on contract principles, and it should go to counsel before the board acts.
How many votes do we need to amend our bylaws?
First read your bylaws, because § 719.106(1)(h) requires them to state a method of amendment and that method controls if it is consistent with the chapter. If the bylaws state no method, § 719.106(1)(h) supplies the default: approval by owners of not less than two-thirds of the voting interests.
Do we have to underline new language in an amendment?
Yes. Section 719.1055(4)(b) requires the amendment to set out the full text of the provision being amended with new words underlined and deleted words lined through with hyphens. If the change is extensive enough that a full markup would obscure it, the amendment may instead carry a notation that there has been a substantial rewording of the document, with a pointer to the provision for the present text.
Our bylaws are from the 1970s and say nothing about reserves. Are we exempt?
No. The statutory requirements apply regardless of what an old bylaw set contains, and § 719.106(1)(j) and (1)(k) carry the reserve and structural integrity reserve study provisions. An out-of-date bylaw set does not create an exemption; it creates a risk that the board will operate from the wrong document.
Can the board adopt rules without a member vote?
It depends on what your bylaws provide. Section 719.106(2)(a) contemplates the bylaws setting out a method of adopting and amending administrative rules governing details of operation and use of the common areas. If your bylaws give that authority to the board, the board may exercise it within the limits of the bylaws, the cooperative documents and the statute. If they do not, the board does not have the power by default.
Contact Hamilton Mikes
Hamilton Mikes reviews and rewrites cooperative document sets for boards across Southwest Florida, including bylaws that predate most of the current statute and proprietary leases that no longer match the form in use. We handle the amendment process from vote threshold through recording. Call 239-594-7227 or visit our Governing Documents page.
Statutes and authorities referenced
- § 719.103(13), Fla. Stat. (definition of cooperative documents)
- § 719.1035, Fla. Stat. (creation; recording; cooperative documents as equitable servitudes running with the land)
- § 719.104(11), Fla. Stat. (powers and duties of the association; part I of chapter 607 and chapter 617)
- § 719.105(1)(a), Fla. Stat. (evidence of membership; legal description; recording under § 201.02(3))
- § 719.1055(1), Fla. Stat. (amendments affecting unit configuration, appurtenances or common expense share; joinder of record owner and lienors)
- § 719.1055(2), (3)(a), Fla. Stat. (acquisition of property; material alterations; alteration, conversion or lease of common areas)
- § 719.1055(4)(a), (b), (c), Fla. Stat. (default amendment threshold; underline and strike-through; substantial rewording notation; nonmaterial errors)
- § 719.106(1)(a)–(o), Fla. Stat. (required bylaw provisions)
- § 719.106(1)(h), Fla. Stat. (amendment of bylaws; two-thirds default)
- § 719.106(2), Fla. Stat. (optional bylaw provisions; administrative rules; use and maintenance restrictions)
- § 719.112, Fla. Stat. (unconscionability of certain leases; rebuttable presumption)
- Part I of Chapter 607 and Chapter 617, Fla. Stat. (corporate law applicable to the association)