Directors are volunteers, and the law does not hold a volunteer to a professional's standard of judgment. It does hold you to a standard of process. A board that reads the packet, asks the questions, takes the advice it needs and records what it did is very hard to second-guess. A board that decides in a hallway and writes it up later is not. This is the one-page version.
Print this and keep it in the front of your board binder. The citations are there so a director can check a statement against the statute rather than take it on faith.
The standard you are held to
- § 718.111(1)(a); § 719.104(9)(a); § 720.303(1)
- § 617.0830, applied by § 718.111(1)(a), § 719.104(9)(a) and § 720.303(1)
- § 617.0830(1)
- The standard is what a prudent person in your position would do, not what an engineer or a lawyer would do. It is a standard of diligence, not of expertise.§ 617.0830(2)
The business judgment rule, and what it does not cover
- § 617.0830(4), (5)(a)
- This is the practical core of the protection. A board that hired a reserve specialist and followed the study is defending a process. A board that guessed is defending a guess.§ 617.0830(4), (5)(b)
- § 617.0830(4), (5)(c)
- Delegation and reliance are two different protections in two different subsections. A board that hands day-to-day enforcement to the manager is relying on performance; a board that reads the manager’s report is relying on information.§ 617.0830(3)
- If the engineer's report contradicts what three owners have told you they saw, reliance is no longer reasonable until you ask.§ 617.0830(3), (4)
The duty of care, in practice
- An oral opinion you cannot produce two years later protects nobody.
- Our board decision documentation worksheet captures this at the time rather than afterward.
- § 718.111(1)(b)
Confidentiality and privilege
- Forwarding a legal memorandum to an owner, a spouse or a vendor can waive the privilege for the whole association, not just for you.
- Closed sessions are limited to attorney-client discussion of proposed or pending litigation and to personnel matters
- § 718.111(12)(c); § 719.104(2)(c); § 720.303(5)(g)
- Whether a message is an official record turns on what it says and what it does, not on the account it was sent from. A litigation hold can reach your personal account and your phone.See board e-mail and text messages
Conflicts of interest
- § 718.3027(1); § 720.3033(2); § 617.0832
- § 718.3027(6); § 468.4335
- The two chapters do not phrase the denominator the same way. Count it the way your chapter phrases it.§ 718.3027(2); § 720.3033(2)
- § 718.3027(4)
- The narrow exception is food consumed at a business meeting worth less than $25 per person.§ 720.3033(3); § 718.3027
You have authority only as a board
- A director who tells a vendor to start work has not hired the vendor. He has created an argument about whether the association has to pay.
- Circulating information is fine. Counting heads is not.
What the president can and cannot do
- Emergency powers: § 718.1265; § 719.128; § 720.316
- Where directors disagree, our page on board disagreements covers the procedural fixes.
- § 718.111(1)(b)
Personal exposure, and its limits
- § 617.0834(1)
- § 617.0834(1)(b)
- § 617.0834(1)(b)
- § 617.0834(2)
- § 718.111(1)(d); § 720.3033(4)
- Ask the agent specifically whether defense costs are inside or outside the limit. Inside-the-limit defense costs can consume the coverage before a claim is resolved.
Statutes and authorities referenced
- § 718.111(1)(a), § 719.104(9)(a), § 720.303(1), Fla. Stat. (fiduciary relationship of officers and directors)
- § 617.0830, Fla. Stat. (general standards for directors; reliance on officers, professionals and committees)
- § 617.0834, Fla. Stat. (immunity of officers and directors of a nonprofit corporation)
- § 718.111(1)(b), Fla. Stat. (each director's vote or abstention recorded in the minutes)
- § 718.111(1)(d), § 720.3033(4), Fla. Stat. (removal of an officer or director charged with a crime)
- § 718.3027, § 720.3033(2), § 617.0832, Fla. Stat. (conflicts of interest)
- § 720.3033(3), Fla. Stat. (kickbacks)
- § 718.111(12)(c), § 719.104(2)(c), § 720.303(5)(g), Fla. Stat. (records not accessible to owners)
- § 718.1265, § 719.128, § 720.316, Fla. Stat. (emergency powers)
Contact Hamilton Mikes
Hamilton Mikes advises Southwest Florida boards on director duties, conflicts, privilege and the coverage that stands behind a board decision, and defends boards when a decision is challenged. Call 239-594-7227 or visit our Corporate Governance page.